Friday, March 18, 2011
The ethics of politics
Friday, November 12, 2010
Rachel Maddow & Jon Stewart talk civility & politics
Wednesday, May 05, 2010
Seek wisdom, not victory (continued)
The problem is that for most of us it's darn hard to turn our backs on victory as a goal. If we make wisdom -- and solving society's problems -- our goal, then we might have to give something up. We might even lose.
If we're politicians, the real solution to a problem might be unpopular and we could end up losing an election. Even worse for one's ego: What if it turns out that our idea of the perfect solution isn't the right solution?
But it is delicious, isn't it, to consider what society might be like if everyone, all at once, sought wisdom instead of victory.
What would happen in Congress? What about Wall Street? If an investment banker suddenly turned away from making money for himself at all costs and re-focused on benefiting his company and society as a whole, what would the economy look like? Would we even be in the mess we are today?
Tuesday, May 04, 2010
Seek wisdom, not victory
5. Seek wisdom, not just victory. Some conservative bloggers, responding to Sanchez and his sympathizers on the right, dismiss conversation with the liberal enemy as a political trap. Creative policy ideas won't bring Republicans to power, argues Jonah Goldberg, and "political reality" dictates that "when liberals control all of the policy-making apparatus, being the party of no is a perfectly rational stance." Hogan, a blogger at Redstate, takes this argument further, reasoning that it's OK to "distill" complex facts to propaganda "when you are at war" with the left. Such ruthlessness might be the surest path to power. But what's the point of power if you haven't learned how to govern? "An open mind seeks wisdom, first and last," writes Millman. I can't put it better than that.I second Millman and humbly amend Saletan's wording. Let's delete the word "just" from his statement and revise it to: Seek wisdom, not victory.
How are we ever going to solve our problems if we've focused on victory and not solutions? And I do equate wisdom with solutions.
I got into politics because I wanted to solve problems. Isn't that the point? Or, am I being too terribly naive here?
Tuesday, June 02, 2009
Left & Right become obsolete
Wednesday, October 15, 2008
The Silly Season
After we've all taken deep breaths and nice, long calming walks in the woods, we need to do whatever we can to ground ourselves in reality. Here are a few ideas on how to do that.
- Remember: No one has won the presidency yet. Days can equal years in politics. Withhold your celebrations or depressions until the night of Nov. 4.
- Ignore the polls. Unless you're a pollster or on Barack Obama or John McCain's campaign staff, they'll only drive you crazy and possibly mislead you. No one wins or loses until all the voters vote. If this election matters to you, it's still important to give money and time to your favorite candidate.
- Read every blogger, including me, with a healthy dose of skepticism. Bloggers tend to view the world through ideology-tinted glasses. That article they claim shows how everyone hates Sarah Palin, for example, may actually say nothing of the sort. Check out the article for yourself.
- And above all, fact check everyone, and that includes me.
Thursday, October 02, 2008
Why McCain & Palin's tactics matter
Sunday, August 12, 2007
Spiritual activism, political revolution & New Age fuzzy thinking
By Diane SilverAt first glance, the idea that political activists should act out of "awareness, compassion and love" seems both ludicrous and suicidal. But acting out of love is the first principle of what Carla Goldstein calls "spiritual activism."
For what it's worth, I wonder if she might be on to something. Following her principle might well provide the key to unlocking the solutions to our most pressing foreign and domestic problems.
I am not suggesting that we open our arms to al Qaeda and say, hey, I love you, shoot me, nor am I recommending that my colleagues in the gay rights movement expect to win equality by hugging Fundamentalists. I quake at the thought of such, shall we say, New Age fuzzy headedness.
Yet I also tremble at the idea that we are going to win our battles by seeking to become more terrifying than our opponents. Right now I worry that we are doing just that. It seems, at times, as if promoting ourselves as the biggest monsters on the block is our only strategy.
In Bush's War on Terror, threatening to kill anyone who threatens us and torturing the people we capture have become standard operating procedures. The neocon solution to terrorism appears to boil down to one simplicity: Kill all the bad guys.
Momentarily leaving aside the morality of such a tactic, I question it's practicality. We cannot, in fact, kill everyone who wants to hurt us. Even if we could, we could not keep from creating more terrorists as we kill the old ones. Every husband or wife we would leave behind could potentially become an enemy. Every brother and sister, every son and daughter, every friend, every acquaintance, every neighbor would have a rock-solid, deep-in-the-heart reason to hate us.
More than that, every one of them would have a personal reason to be terrified of us. Bush and friends foolishly think that creating fear in our enemies will keep them from fighting back. But I ask: Would it stop us if we were in their situation?
I live in Lawrence, Kan., and sometimes I wonder what my neighbors would do it we were facing an occupation like Bush and friends have imposed on Iraq. Even if the invaders were first seen as liberators, how would Kansans feel this many years in and with so many of our neighbors dead or imprisoned? At what point would Kansans take up arms against the people who invaded our country?
Finally, if we felt like our backs were to the wall, and we had no chance except to fight back against the terrifying monsters or die, would we befriend the people who were scaring us? Or, would we fight back any way we could?
To believe that Iraqis and other Muslims are a different breed of human, that they they don't hate and fear and love like we do, is simply crazy. But that seems to be the neocon/Bush belief.
The same is true about domestic issues. Attempting to be the biggest monster in the room won't save Fundamentalists or lesbians or gays or Democrats or Republicans. At times, it seems that fear is the only political tactic that campaigns want to employ. It is true that fear does move voters for an election or two, but I wonder what we create when we only evoke fear in our campaigns? Does such a victory sow the seeds of the next domestic war?
And yes, I know that my discussion of these challenges is too brief and simplistic, but those are issues we can return to on other days. Such is the joy of a blog.
For this moment, though, here's why I think acting out of love and compassion is so important: Acting out of fear makes us stupid. Adrenaline pumps and the primal brain takes over. We don't take time to consider. We don't take time to find lasting solutions. Instead, we go into survival mode.
Personally, I think acting out of fear makes it hard for human beings to see reality. Above all, these days, a good sense of reality has got to be a requirement.
In the second column in her series on spiritual activism, Goldstein touches more deeply on the workings of that first principle, which is:
"We take action that is born out of awareness, compassion and love, not out of reaction, fear and anger."
Goldstein provides some first steps on how to open up and become more loving. My hope is that this modest post will provide some explanation as to why such activities are important.
The courage to open to our hearts has the potential to change everything. Goldstein writes:
As a result of my heartfulness practice, my activism has radically changed. It has gone from being something I do to accomplish a social change goal to a way of being. I have come to understand that the means and the end are equally important, which brings me to know that yelling at “the other side” (or my daughter) is doing exactly the same thing I am condemning – creating fear and anger. The more I get in touch with my own heart, the more I am in touch with the hearts of others and the more interested I become in cultivating peace rather than polarization.
This post continues a journey I began last week when I first commented on Goldstein's work.
I'm calling this a journey because I freely admit that I don't have all the answers, or perhaps even many of them. What I do have is an itch, a sense gnawing at me, that we have to change the way we do politics and activism, or we will never move forward as a nation. I plan to comment on each of Goldstein's columns on spiritual activism in the hope of sparking conversation and finding more answers.
Saturday, December 16, 2006
The mainstream media should have done better by Sen. Johnson
By Nancy Jane MooreThe media reaction to Sen. Tim Johnson's recent health emergency was annoying, inappropriate, and -- for the first several days -- inaccurate.
Every initial story about the South Dakota senator's illness focused more on the fact that a Republican governor would name any replacement than it did on what happened to him and how he was faring. Not only did this rudely reduce Sen. Johnson to a cipher who is more important as one of the people who make up the Democratic majority than he is a human being, but every story left the incorrect impression that he would be replaced immediately if he didn't get well and even that he could be replaced temporarily.
In fact, the governor can only replace him if he dies or if he resigns. And he doesn't have to resign, even if he's too ill to return to his duties when the Senate reconvenes. Senators do not have to step down because of illness, even if they're seriously incapacitated. History is rife with examples of senators who were out for extended periods due to their health and others who were barely able to make it to the floor for a vote.
Further, there are no "temporary" replacements. The Senate does without any members who can't be there.
The only initial report on Sen. Johnson that got it right wasn't in the mainstream press, but on the blog Balkinization. Sandy Levinson, a constitutional scholar who thinks we should address ways of removing disabled senators, explained it clearly:
In any event, so long as Johnson is alive, he remains the Senator from South Dakota and the Democrats will have a 50-49 majority of those present and voting in early January. This means that under no circumstances, whatever the seriousness of his condition, should he be viewed as "resigning" his seat, given the political realities of the situation.And it took a couple of days before even supposedly politically astute publications like The New York Times and The Washington Post got it right. And they're still more interested in the political ramifications than they are in Sen. Johnson's health, as witnessed by today's Post story, which focuses on the wild and wooly world of South Dakota politics.
I realize that right now most of the news about Sen. Johnson is some variation on "wait and see." But health problems suffered by public figures also provide an opportunity to educate the public. Since Sen. Johnson had stroke-like symptoms, but did not, in fact, have a stroke, articles on the aneurysms and the many other kinds of brain injuries that can occur in seemingly healthy individuals would be much more valuable than all this political speculation.
Ironically, the best words on the subject came from Mississippi Sen. Trent Lott, a Republican who is posed to become the minority whip in the new Senate. The Washington Post quotes Lott:
My expectation and hope is that Tim will recover fully and come back and we'll go to work. You know, I'd like to be in the majority, but I don't want to do it that way.We here on In This Moment also wish Sen. Johnson a speedy recovery.


