Showing posts with label Carla Goldstein. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Carla Goldstein. Show all posts

Tuesday, November 27, 2007

Angry, Yet Still Connected: Searching for answers in a world of enemies

By Diane Silver

I've been reading Carla Goldstein's fascinating columns on what she has dubbed "spiritual activism," and find myself both thrilled and frustrated. In her third column, she explores the concept of interdependence.

I agree with everything she says, although I worry that her to-do list is so imposing it will frighten people off.

What frustrates me, though, is what she doesn't discuss. That is the very real problem of dealing with my dependence on and connections to my enemies.

I would love to believe that I live in a world where no one wants to hurt me and my family, but as a lesbian, feminist, progressive and an American, I know that isn't true.

Let me count just a few of the ways that I and many others face enemies: As a lesbian, I face thousands (millions?) of people who want to deny me equal rights under the law. They fight every attempt I make to gain fairness for myself and my family.

When my son was young, some of them would have even taken him away and orphaned him for no other reason than the fact that I'm a lesbian. They blame me for society's ills. Some of them spew such hateful rhetoric that it can be used to justify any act or any attack against me and my family.

As a feminist and progressive, I'm often accused of being a traitor or worse. As an American, I am subject to attack by terrorists who don't care who they kill simply to make a political point or to get back at the real sins of our government.

Having enemies scares me.

Having enemies makes me want to run and hide.

Having enemies makes me want to smash them before they smash me.

And yet...

I know full well that we breathe the same air. We walk the same Earth, our feet touch the same soil. In my relatively small college town, some of us even shop at the same grocery store. We want the same things such as happiness and prosperity of body and soul and the freedom to live as we wish. We want our kids to go to good schools. We want them to grow up in a healthy country full of abundance.

The truth is that I really don't want to destroy my enemies. I simply don't want them to destroy me.

I even wish I could think of a better name -- the word "enemy" is so hateful and frightening. Using the word makes me think that I have no other choice than to destroy them before they "get" me. Must I grind the Religious Right into dust, so that my family can survive? Must I -- represented by the U.S. government and military -- kill, maim and torture thousands in the Middle East to stay safe?

And if I do grind "them" (those dastardly bad guys) into dust, whether politically or through actual murder, can I destroy them all, or will some survive to seek revenge against me?

From where I sit, the real trick of interdependence is figuring out how to get past my fear and theirs. In a world of enemies (and in their minds, I am most decidedly their enemy), what can we do? How can we see that we are all on the same side, no matter what theology or philosophy we preach? How do we make peace without surrendering?

At this moment, the toughest task we face is how to make peace. How can we bring the Middle East together? How can we end terrorism without creating more terrorists through our own violence? How can we make peace in America's culture war without destroying either side?

I am hungry for peace because I am truly tired of fighting.

PHOTO: Carla Goldstein

Sunday, August 12, 2007

Spiritual activism, political revolution & New Age fuzzy thinking

By Diane Silver

At first glance, the idea that political activists should act out of "awareness, compassion and love" seems both ludicrous and suicidal. But acting out of love is the first principle of what Carla Goldstein calls "spiritual activism."

For what it's worth, I wonder if she might be on to something. Following her principle might well provide the key to unlocking the solutions to our most pressing foreign and domestic problems.

I am not suggesting that we open our arms to al Qaeda and say, hey, I love you, shoot me, nor am I recommending that my colleagues in the gay rights movement expect to win equality by hugging Fundamentalists. I quake at the thought of such, shall we say, New Age fuzzy headedness.

Yet I also tremble at the idea that we are going to win our battles by seeking to become more terrifying than our opponents. Right now I worry that we are doing just that. It seems, at times, as if promoting ourselves as the biggest monsters on the block is our only strategy.

In Bush's War on Terror, threatening to kill anyone who threatens us and torturing the people we capture have become standard operating procedures. The neocon solution to terrorism appears to boil down to one simplicity: Kill all the bad guys.

Momentarily leaving aside the morality of such a tactic, I question it's practicality. We cannot, in fact, kill everyone who wants to hurt us. Even if we could, we could not keep from creating more terrorists as we kill the old ones. Every husband or wife we would leave behind could potentially become an enemy. Every brother and sister, every son and daughter, every friend, every acquaintance, every neighbor would have a rock-solid, deep-in-the-heart reason to hate us.

More than that, every one of them would have a personal reason to be terrified of us. Bush and friends foolishly think that creating fear in our enemies will keep them from fighting back. But I ask: Would it stop us if we were in their situation?

I live in Lawrence, Kan., and sometimes I wonder what my neighbors would do it we were facing an occupation like Bush and friends have imposed on Iraq. Even if the invaders were first seen as liberators, how would Kansans feel this many years in and with so many of our neighbors dead or imprisoned? At what point would Kansans take up arms against the people who invaded our country?

Finally, if we felt like our backs were to the wall, and we had no chance except to fight back against the terrifying monsters or die, would we befriend the people who were scaring us? Or, would we fight back any way we could?

To believe that Iraqis and other Muslims are a different breed of human, that they they don't hate and fear and love like we do, is simply crazy. But that seems to be the neocon/Bush belief.

The same is true about domestic issues. Attempting to be the biggest monster in the room won't save Fundamentalists or lesbians or gays or Democrats or Republicans. At times, it seems that fear is the only political tactic that campaigns want to employ. It is true that fear does move voters for an election or two, but I wonder what we create when we only evoke fear in our campaigns? Does such a victory sow the seeds of the next domestic war?

And yes, I know that my discussion of these challenges is too brief and simplistic, but those are issues we can return to on other days. Such is the joy of a blog.

For this moment, though, here's why I think acting out of love and compassion is so important: Acting out of fear makes us stupid. Adrenaline pumps and the primal brain takes over. We don't take time to consider. We don't take time to find lasting solutions. Instead, we go into survival mode.

Personally, I think acting out of fear makes it hard for human beings to see reality. Above all, these days, a good sense of reality has got to be a requirement.

In the second column in her series on spiritual activism, Goldstein touches more deeply on the workings of that first principle, which is:
"We take action that is born out of awareness, compassion and love, not out of reaction, fear and anger."

Goldstein provides some first steps on how to open up and become more loving. My hope is that this modest post will provide some explanation as to why such activities are important.

The courage to open to our hearts has the potential to change everything. Goldstein writes:

As a result of my heartfulness practice, my activism has radically changed. It has gone from being something I do to accomplish a social change goal to a way of being. I have come to understand that the means and the end are equally important, which brings me to know that yelling at “the other side” (or my daughter) is doing exactly the same thing I am condemning – creating fear and anger. The more I get in touch with my own heart, the more I am in touch with the hearts of others and the more interested I become in cultivating peace rather than polarization.

This post continues a journey I began last week when I first commented on Goldstein's work.

I'm calling this a journey because I freely admit that I don't have all the answers, or perhaps even many of them. What I do have is an itch, a sense gnawing at me, that we have to change the way we do politics and activism, or we will never move forward as a nation. I plan to comment on each of Goldstein's columns on spiritual activism in the hope of sparking conversation and finding more answers.

Wednesday, August 08, 2007

In search of a political revolution

By Diane Silver

I've spent decades working in politics as a political reporter in mainstream media, a blogger in the ungoverned wilds of the blogosphere, a staff member for both a candidate campaign and an issue campaign, and a gay rights activist.

I've come to believe that politics and activism are noble pursuits. They are, after all, the means by which citizens of a democracy move government and society forward. My goal has always been to do what's right, to help people, to make a difference.

For years, though, I've felt a bit lost. Oh, I keep doing the work, but I have this gnawing sense, call it an itch in the stomach, that there is something inherently wrong with the way we're doing things today.

This itch is turning into a knot in the gut and a fear that the way we do politics is creating as many problems as bad laws and corrupt and power hungry politicians.

This fear is not about any political party, activist organization or particular cause. It's about the attitudes held and the activities pursued by people of all political persuasions.

I've mulled this over for quite a while without coming up with many ideas about what a different way of doing politics and activism would look like. Luckily, I don't have to keep mulling this problem alone.

The idea that we need to do something different -- in essence, give birth to a new kind of political revolution -- is gaining steam.

Several new books tackle the issue from a Buddhist perspective. Mindful Politics was published in 2006. The Engaged Spiritual Life: A Buddhist Approach to Transforming Ourselves and the World came out the same year. Buddhist teacher Pema Chodron took on the issue in Practicing Peace in Times of War.

These are by no means the only books on the subject. They are just the ones I know about, and I welcome people's recommendations. I haven't had a chance to read all of those books, so I'll postpone commenting on them for the moment.

Today, though, I was thrilled to stumble upon a new column called "Spiritual Activism" by Carla Goldstein, director of The Women’s Institute at Omega. A longtime participant in politics and activism, Goldstein sets out her basic argument for a new kind of political revolution in her first column. I think she's dead on target with her assessment.

Goldstein writes (and the emphasis is mine):

As a young boomer I learned about activism from the civil rights movement, the women’s movement, and the anti-war movement—all groups that had to fight for power and rights. I carried that model into my own life as a lawyer and professional advocate, learning to trace a social problem to its source, which always had at its center a villain—a political party, a corporation, an ideology. To me, activism meant organizing with others to fight the villains to fix the problem, the operative word being “fight.”
...
(R)elationships are central to everything and really matter. Process matters. While an adversarial approach can often be effective in the short-term, in the long-term, we are perpetuating that which we are fighting against. When we are purely adversarial, the very mechanism we use to bring about more peace, compassion and justice, ends up creating the byproduct of fear, insecurity and anger. While the fighting model served an important historic purpose and may still be necessary in some circumstances, we need a new transformational framework that evolves beyond the ancient cycle of anger and war.

Goldstein proposes a list of "emerging principles" to guide this new model of activism. It's almost impossible to understand these principles without reading her longer explanations, but just to get the discussion going, here's her list.

1. Awareness, Compassion and Love
2. Interdependence
3. Empowerment
4. The Means Matter
5. Mindfulness and Presence
6. Paradox and Mystery
7. Seeking Balance
8. Open to Suffering
9. Beyond Proximate Cause
10. Living Our Values

I have one small quibble with Goldstein's approach.

I consider myself a spiritual and religious person, but I wince at Goldstein's use of the term "spiritual." Not only may the term push away potential allies, but it may also be inaccurate. Neither spirituality nor religion are the only paths to this new paradigm for activism. To call this "spiritual activism" is to imply that compassion and emotional maturity come only from one place.

Aside from that minor disagreement, I am thrilled to see Goldstein's entry into this important discussion.

It is long past time for Americans, in particular, to grow up. I fear that if we do not find a new maturity in our public life, then we will not be able to heal our nation.

Without that kind of healing, it may well be impossible to ever safeguard ourselves against terrorists and other dangers to our security, to protect our environment and meet the challenge of global warming, and to bring equality, fairness and economic opportunity to all our citizens.

---------

PHOTO: The sun rises over Lake Ontario to symbolize a new day and a new approach to life in the public square.