Monday, September 22, 2008
Mainstream Media & the Bailout: Getting the story wrong
McClatchy Newspapers on Friday:
The next president will take office in January with little hope of getting his pet programs enacted quickly, if at all, because of already-massive budget deficits likely to balloon even further from the hundreds of billions expected to be used to bail out Wall Street.Time magazine today:
For at least the next year, and perhaps for years after, Treasury's spending authority will make it harder for the next President to fulfill campaign promises and pump money into new priorities.I added the italics.
The problem with both of these passages is that they turn this into a story about the problems of a politician. The idea that it's only this poor soul's "pet programs" and his ability to "fulfill campaign promises" that is hurt is complete and utter garbage.
While it is factually true that the new president will face problems, his tussles will be tiny compared to what's going to happen to the rest of us.
This bailout -- no matter how necessary -- means that you and I won't get universal health care, at least not anytime soon. Crumbling bridges may well not be fixed because the U.S. government won't have the money. (Can anyone say "Minneapolis?") FEMA may be even less effective than it is now. Financial aid for college students could well shrink. Medical research and other scientific research could be hampered because the U.S. Treasury is strapped for cash. The list goes on and on.
There will be much less money available to provide the kind of services citizens need and should expect from their government.
By framing the story as being about presidential problems, journalists make it appear as if this is a mere political hassle for one guy who lives in the White House. Who cares if a politician has to wrestle with campaign promises?
From my vantage point, the Bailout looks a tad too much like highway robbery. It could hurt all of us for decades to come.
Thursday, September 04, 2008
Today's Must Read: An "apology" to Sarah Palin
Sunday, August 17, 2008
Today's Must Read: The Hidden John McCain
Like Josh Marshall at Talking Points Memo, I believe it's time for the news media to stop grading McCain on a curve and start looking at the real man behind the image.
Sunday, June 24, 2007
Since when is the only enemy we're fighting Al Qaeda?
In his blog on Salon, Glenn Greenwald points out that most recent war news reports name the enemy exclusively as "Al Qaeda."
Greenwald, whose piece begins with a cite from Josh Marshall's Talking Points Memo, suggests that this is an orchestrated campaign by the Bush administration: Since support for the Iraq War has reached an all-time low, the Bushies are raising the spectre of Al Qaeda to scare us back into a pro-war stance. He writes:
All of a sudden, every time one of the top military commanders describes our latest operations or quantifies how many we killed, the enemy is referred to, almost exclusively now, as "Al Qaeda."
That's bad enough, but the part that really worries me is that the mainstream press seems to be going along with this description. Greenwald says:
[W]hat is even more notable is that the establishment press has followed right along, just as enthusiastically. I don't think the New York Times has published a story about Iraq in the last two weeks without stating that we are killing "Al Qaeda fighters," capturing "Al Qaeda leaders," and every new operation is against "Al Qaeda."
He also mentions similar coverage on CNN and in The Washington Post.
I've noticed the same thing on NPR. In fact, I've found myself yelling at the radio, "Why are you calling all the insurgents Al Qaeda?"
If you follow war news at all -- and particularly if you make a point of reading the broad coverage available on Juan Cole's Informed Comment and often read the detailed reporting of Seymour Hersh in the New Yorker (his most recent article shows how a general's career was ruined because he actually investigated what happened at Abu Ghraib) -- you know that the insurgents in Iraq represent a wide variety of interests. Even the ones who actually use the name Al Qaeda have little or nothing to do with Osama bin Laden and those who attacked the United States.
It's pointless to expect honesty from the Bush administration. But it's absurd to see supposedly competent news sources reporting these statements without even questioning their accuracy. This is exactly the same kind of unquestioning reporting they did in the lead-up to the war itself.
Given that most of the media have expressed regret and even repentance about their earlier naive acceptance of administration lies, it is shocking to see them once again just parroting what they hear. Why aren't they asking the simple question, "Excuse me, but what makes these particular insurgents Al Qaeda?"
If they get an unsatisfactory answer -- as they undoubtedly will -- they can report that as well. And then they can call up sources who know better and try to get closer to the truth.
We all now know that every statement from the Bush administration must be checked against reliable sources. The mainstream press cannot lie down on the job again.
Update:
In this morning's Iraq War roundup on NPR's Morning Edition, I am pleased to note that the reporter and the host did not once use the term Al Qaeda to describe the insurgents. I am glad that some reporters are paying attention.
Monday, June 04, 2007
Paris Hilton goes to jail
Paris Hilton has now spent her first night in jail, and I'd like to state for the record that I honestly don't give two hoots in a holler. I don't care if she's spoiled, a victim of fame, misunderstood or whatever.
I am pleased that she hasn't mowed anyone down with her car while driving under the influence. I am not-so-thrilled, however, with the media fascination with her. Do we not have a few other things to discuss that are a tad more important? Ah, you know, like a war, Congressional corruption, genocide, health insurance, an upcoming presidential election.
Oh, but I am so old fashioned.
End of rant.
Tuesday, April 10, 2007
Even mainstream journalists get sick of themselves, & I remember why
By Diane SilverA column over at the Roanoke Times in Virgina reminded me about the frustrations of my newspaper days.
I used to cover the Kansas Legislature for The Wichita Eagle. My life partner would laugh that she got the best Statehouse coverage of anyone in Kansas. That's because I'd come home from work and tell her the stories I couldn't get into print.
It wasn't an issue of censorship so much as an issue of (1) priorities (2) time and/or (3) the conventions of the MSM.
Priorities often became an argument between what I thought was important and what the executive editor, the state editor, the assistant state editor, etc., thought was important. Their priorities weren't always my priorities, and frankly, I don't think the editors' priorities were always what was most important to the people of Kansas or our readers.
In the world of academia that I inhabited as a journalism grad student before coming to Kansas, we used to passionately argue about the true definition of news. We'd ask: What is it? What should the definition of news be?
When I got out here to Kansas I learned that there really was only one definition of news in the newsroom, and it was somewhat of a joke. News was whatever happened to ____ and his friends. That blank is the name of the top dog in the newsroom. Thus, I would sometimes be sent off to cover a minor bill, not because it would effect the lives of many Kansans but because it would impact a few rich folk -- that is ole' so and so and his friends.
I honestly don't think there was any evil intent in this. It was just a matter of perspective and a few folks' inability to walk in the shoes of our readers.
Time was also a big issue. You can't cover everything, no matter how hard you try. Thus, important stories were often missed. The corollary to time was of course space. The newspaper could only print so much news on any given day.
Finally, the conventions of the business hemmed reporters. Roanoke's Dan Radmacher mentions that in his column when he talks about the practice of "bracketing the truth." In other words, a reporter gets "both sides of the story," whether or not there are two sides, three sides, or 43 sides, or only one side, to what is actually happening.
Many reporters also believe they've done their job if they simply quote both sides of an issue -- as if most issues only have two sides -- with no further effort to get at the truth of the matter.Radmacher puts this off to laziness, but I think there's more to it than that. I remember many times when I was required to get "two sides," no matter how many sides really existed. (This happens often today in coverage of the gay rights movement.)
I also remember being so stretched by deadlines that I didn't have the time to find the information and to verify it in order to show that the "two sides" idea was wrong. If you have to fill the news hole and you have to write something, then it is always easier to quote Dude A and Dude B and let it go at that. (By the way, these usually were dudes, as in male officials.)
Finally, I wonder if we've reached a point where it's time to actually call politicians (can anyone say George W. Bush?) on their lies. Radmacher's column does a great job of showing all the times Bush has lied, yet the ultimate "L" word is seldom used with Bush. I think it's time to dust that delightful word off and finally tell a bit of truth.
Friday, March 09, 2007
Death by newsprint, and other sad tales of the newspaper industry
Monday, February 05, 2007
Climate Change: We all fiddle while the world burns
The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change told the world Feb. 2 that evidence of global warming is "unequivocal." Their "Summary for Policymakers" (PDF) of their report, Climate Change 2007: The Physical Science Basis, pointed out not only that the change in global climate is due to human activity, but also that even if we make necessary changes now, the human race will still have to deal with the environmental repercussions for centuries to come.
According to The New York Times, the Bush administration said it "embraced" the findings and noted that it had "played a leading role" in climate research. However, The Times also noted that Energy Secretary Samuel Bodman rejected the idea that the U.S. should adopt a national limit on carbon emissions. According to The Times, Bodman said, "We are a small contributor to the overall, when you look at the rest of the world, so it's really got to be a global solution."
In its next paragraph, The Times said:
The United States, with about 5 percent of the world’s population, contributes about a quarter of greenhouse gas emissions, more than any other country.The Times clearly thought this was the most important story on Feb. 2. The lead headline on The Times online all day Friday was:
Science Panel Says Global Warming Is 'Unequivocal'But The Washington Post didn't give it the same play. Its lead story for most of Feb. 2 was the Iraq War. Late in the day, that was topped by "President Reaching Out To House Democrats." Global warming played second fiddle to those stories.
The Times made the right call, but The Post coverage shows just how big a problem there is in dealing with climate change. And once both had covered the IPCC report, climate change issues drew substantially less coverage. The Post did run a story on how the U.S., China, and India -- the world's heaviest polluter coupled with the two most populous nations -- declined to participate in a new environmental body suggested by France.
Global warming is the most important issue facing the world today, but even major newspapers rarely give it adequate attention. They are much more comfortable covering war and politics than in dealing with the crisis that is going to define the 21st Century.
To some extent, this is inevitable. Climate change is a long term problem, but war and politics always provide immediate crises -- breaking news. Both the news business and the human mind respond more quickly to trouble at hand than they do to trouble down the road.
And, in truth, the catastrophic results of the Bush administration's failed invasion of Iraq has created another long term crisis that will affect much of the world. But even chaos in the Middle East pales by comparison to the problems the human race will suffer from climate change, particularly if we don't get a handle on solutions soon.
Meanwhile, the world's two largest energy companies, ExxonMobil and Royal Dutch Shell, earned record profits in 2006 -- $180 million/day, according to The Times.
The Union of Concerned Scientists pointed out back in January that Exxon is using Big Tobacco's tactics to undercut global warming research.
Incidentally, the UK publication, the Guardian, pointed out on Feb. 2 that the American Enterprise Institute has offered $10,000 to any scientists or economists who can undercut the IPCC report. The Guardian said:
Letters sent by the American Enterprise Institute (AEI), an ExxonMobil-funded thinktank with close links to the Bush administration, offered the payments for articles that emphasise the shortcomings of a report from the UN's Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC).It seems that every report we see on climate change shows that the problem is even worse than we thought. But wealthy Big Oil -- with the usual short-sightedness of big business driven by short term profit -- keeps trying to muddy the waters. And the Bush administration -- which is virtually a subsidiary of Big Oil -- keeps making sure the U.S. does nothing to contribute to the solution.
Meanwhile the press -- and the rest of us -- are distracted by the Iraq War, by current politics, and by Bush's campaign to convince us that terrorism is the bigger crisis.
And so we continue doing nothing to address the most important issue facing the world today.
Tuesday, January 16, 2007
If we are going to change the world, we have to throw out our old ideas about news
In my first post at Becoming The Change, I talked about how one of the routine chores of this blog will be to look at the news from a changemaker's perspective.
The next thought that popped into my head, of course, was: So, what the heck IS a changemaker's perspective?
Read more...
Saturday, December 16, 2006
The mainstream media should have done better by Sen. Johnson
By Nancy Jane MooreThe media reaction to Sen. Tim Johnson's recent health emergency was annoying, inappropriate, and -- for the first several days -- inaccurate.
Every initial story about the South Dakota senator's illness focused more on the fact that a Republican governor would name any replacement than it did on what happened to him and how he was faring. Not only did this rudely reduce Sen. Johnson to a cipher who is more important as one of the people who make up the Democratic majority than he is a human being, but every story left the incorrect impression that he would be replaced immediately if he didn't get well and even that he could be replaced temporarily.
In fact, the governor can only replace him if he dies or if he resigns. And he doesn't have to resign, even if he's too ill to return to his duties when the Senate reconvenes. Senators do not have to step down because of illness, even if they're seriously incapacitated. History is rife with examples of senators who were out for extended periods due to their health and others who were barely able to make it to the floor for a vote.
Further, there are no "temporary" replacements. The Senate does without any members who can't be there.
The only initial report on Sen. Johnson that got it right wasn't in the mainstream press, but on the blog Balkinization. Sandy Levinson, a constitutional scholar who thinks we should address ways of removing disabled senators, explained it clearly:
In any event, so long as Johnson is alive, he remains the Senator from South Dakota and the Democrats will have a 50-49 majority of those present and voting in early January. This means that under no circumstances, whatever the seriousness of his condition, should he be viewed as "resigning" his seat, given the political realities of the situation.And it took a couple of days before even supposedly politically astute publications like The New York Times and The Washington Post got it right. And they're still more interested in the political ramifications than they are in Sen. Johnson's health, as witnessed by today's Post story, which focuses on the wild and wooly world of South Dakota politics.
I realize that right now most of the news about Sen. Johnson is some variation on "wait and see." But health problems suffered by public figures also provide an opportunity to educate the public. Since Sen. Johnson had stroke-like symptoms, but did not, in fact, have a stroke, articles on the aneurysms and the many other kinds of brain injuries that can occur in seemingly healthy individuals would be much more valuable than all this political speculation.
Ironically, the best words on the subject came from Mississippi Sen. Trent Lott, a Republican who is posed to become the minority whip in the new Senate. The Washington Post quotes Lott:
My expectation and hope is that Tim will recover fully and come back and we'll go to work. You know, I'd like to be in the majority, but I don't want to do it that way.We here on In This Moment also wish Sen. Johnson a speedy recovery.
Monday, November 13, 2006
Topeka Capital-Journal misses the point on Kansas Congressman Jerry Moran
By Diane SilverThis weekend The Topeka Capital-Journal gave a good example of why the mainstream media is often the subject of hoots of derision.
In a worshipful article that called Republican incumbent Jerry Moran the "avalanche man" for posting a huge victory over his Democratic opponent, the newspaper failed to note an important point: Moran's "opposition" was a no-name, no-experience, never-run-before unknown. Democrat John Doll has never even run for dog catcher before, as far as I know.
If Moran had not been able to beat Doll, that would have been news.
The fact that Moran won a sixth term with 79 percent of the vote -- even in a banner year for Democrats -- doesn't prove a thing, except that Kansas Democrats needs to recruit better candidates. Moran's district is also the most conservative in the state.
As far as I can tell, Doll's only claim to fame is posting a diary on Daily Kos. That's an interesting idea, but it doesn't have much to do with campaigning in the huge 1st District of western Kansas.


