Showing posts with label William Saletan. Show all posts
Showing posts with label William Saletan. Show all posts

Wednesday, May 05, 2010

Seek wisdom, not victory (continued)

William Saletan has commented that his original formulation of "seek wisdom, not just victory" was an attempt to get victory-oriented people to listen, and not a statement of his true feelings. I certainly understand and endorse the need to appeal to one's win-at-all-cost audience. If people won't listen, nothing will change.

The problem is that for most of us it's darn hard to turn our backs on victory as a goal. If we make wisdom -- and solving society's problems -- our goal, then we might have to give something up. We might even lose.

If we're politicians, the real solution to a problem might be unpopular and we could end up losing an election. Even worse for one's ego: What if it turns out that our idea of the perfect solution isn't the right solution?

But it is delicious, isn't it, to consider what society might be like if everyone, all at once, sought wisdom instead of victory.

What would happen in Congress? What about Wall Street? If an investment banker suddenly turned away from making money for himself at all costs and re-focused on benefiting his company and society as a whole, what would the economy look like? Would we even be in the mess we are today?

Tuesday, May 04, 2010

Seek wisdom, not victory

Following up on yesterday's post about civility and politics, I want to point to William Saletan's overview of the current bloggy allegation that conservatives have closed their minds, slammed all the windows and doors, and nailed them shut. (AKA "epistemic closure.") Saletan offers 10 ways to crawl out of group think, including this one.
5. Seek wisdom, not just victory. Some conservative bloggers, responding to Sanchez and his sympathizers on the right, dismiss conversation with the liberal enemy as a political trap. Creative policy ideas won't bring Republicans to power, argues Jonah Goldberg, and "political reality" dictates that "when liberals control all of the policy-making apparatus, being the party of no is a perfectly rational stance." Hogan, a blogger at Redstate, takes this argument further, reasoning that it's OK to "distill" complex facts to propaganda "when you are at war" with the left. Such ruthlessness might be the surest path to power. But what's the point of power if you haven't learned how to govern? "An open mind seeks wisdom, first and last," writes Millman. I can't put it better than that.
I second Millman and humbly amend Saletan's wording. Let's delete the word "just" from his statement and revise it to: Seek wisdom, not victory.

How are we ever going to solve our problems if we've focused on victory and not solutions? And I do equate wisdom with solutions.

I got into politics because I wanted to solve problems. Isn't that the point? Or, am I being too terribly naive here?